Timothy Cole had his college education cut short. Being charged with rape and sentenced to 25 years in prison will do that. He was offered parole, provided he admit guilt, but he declined. He maintained his innocence until the day he died, 13 years into his sentence. Nine years later, DNA evidence convinced the court to see things his way. On February 6th, 2009, a district court judge announced "to a 100 percent moral, factual and legal certainty" that Timothy Cole did not commit the rape. That his exoneration came posthumously makes it even more heartrending a story. :o(His is one of 266 names absolved by the Innocence Project: "a national litigation and public policy organization dedicated to exonerating wrongfully convicted people through DNA testing and reforming the criminal justice system to prevent further injustice."
Forensic scientists use DNA profiling to identify individuals on a genomic level. That technique must be mind-bogglingly complicated! Nah, they've narrowed it down to 13 number pairs. And they get those number pairs from regions of DNA that don't even code for anything. Affectionately dubbed "junk dna."Here's a sample DNA profile:
7/5, 6/3, 4/7, 8/5, 6/9, 7/7, 9/5, 8/6, 7/9, 6/5, 5/4, 3/9, 5/4.
A number stands for the variable number tandem repeat (vntr). This is the amount of times a chemical sequence repeats at a specific location on that chromosome. So for example, the first number duo in the profile above is 7/5. This means that there were 7 repeats on one chromosome, and 5 on the other (one chromosome from mom, one from pop). Each number duo stands for a chromosome pair (Don't we have 23 chromosome pairs? Yea, they only use 13. Y'think that's slacking? The UK only uses 10). If I failed horribly at explaining that and you want more of the nitty geeky: Wikipedia Entry and Some Textbook Excerpt and Human Genome Project
Back to story time: DNA can be a double-edged sword. Where it rightfully exculpates some, like Timothy Cole, it wrongfully inculpates others. Lydia Fairchild's DNA results did not match that of her own children when she applied for welfare. "Fairchild was not only denied government assistance,...she was now suspected of possibly acting as a paid surrogate mother and committing welfare fraud." She'd have lost custody of her kids, had her lawyer not researched the medical phenomena known as chimerism.
Sometimes two fertilized eggs meant to be twins fuse into "one fetus that carries two distinct genetic codes -- two separate strands of DNA." So while DNA from Lydia's hair and skin cells didn't match that of her kids, those from other body tissues, like her cervical cells, did match. Her story is an example of overestimating the validity of DNA rulings.Sometimes DNA evidence only leads police on a wild goose chase. In Germany, there was a woman serial killer, whose trail was as prolific as it was unpredictable. Her DNA showed up repeatedly at crime scenes, but she managed to evade police capture. She seemed almost ghostly to the puzzled authorities and frightened public - Having no other clues to her existence besides her reliably present DNA calling card. Turns out a little old lady who worked in the factory that made the DNA swabs was unknowingly contaminating them. Oops.

These are some of the aggregated cases in Dr. Sheldon Krimsky's book, Genetic Justice. Its aggressive agenda to expose the use of forensic DNA as a threat to our civil liberties is not easily ignored. Law enforcement agents increasingly challenge the fourth amendment by surreptitiously collecting DNA samples without a warrant; a scenario exemplified in State of Washington vs. Athan. The police had a DNA sample from a rape/homicide and suspected Athan to be the perpetrator. They wanted a sample of his DNA to test for a match and created a ruse to get it. The detectives posed as lawyers from a fictitious law firm and wrote Athan a letter inviting him to be their client in a class action suit filed against municipalities that overcharged on parking tickets." Athan sent back the form, after filling it out and licking the envelope (why hello saliva sample!). The police confirmed his DNA as a match to that found at the crime scene and he was convicted.The court turned a blind eye to the fact that police had made a mockery of Attorney-Client Privileges by posing as his lawyers. The court didn't care about the Obstruction of Correspondence (a typically imprisonable offense) when police opened a sealed envelope intended for another person. Nor did the court mind that Athan's DNA, which they ruled to be "abandoned property," had been obtained without his consent. I don't feel too bad for him, because he did rape and murder a 13 year old girl....but objectively speaking, his right to a fair trail was compromised.
Ever heard of the Statute of Limitations? DNA hasn't. A John Doe Indictment is another way Police use DNA to circumvent an enactment in the common law legal system. This increasingly popular method issues a warrant onto an anonymous DNA profile on the day that the case would otherwise go cold. With a warrant out for the arrest of John Doe, the case is suspended, giving cops an indefinite grace period to cash in on it. It's pretty clever actually. And I'm tempted to high five police officers for it. But I'm reminded that they're compromising the law. But it's to catch bad guys! Aaaagh, the internal debate rages.
Of more contentious debate is whether there should be universal DNA profiling. The genetic information of criminals is compiled in a nationwide database called the CODIS. Proponents say the innocent commonfolk's information should be thrown in the mix. They assert that if you are a law-abiding individual, you'd have no qualms with entering your information in a registry. Opponents point out the fallibility of DNA rulings, and don't discount the possibility of an innocent person being genetically framed. DNA may be immutable, foolproof....but humans aren't. We can make mistakes in reading DNA. We can make false judgments or quick assumptions. Houston and Chicago labs have been closed down, for faulty techniques. The samples collected from crime scenes are rarely clean, and often contaminated. Sometimes far too scanty to provide a reliable reading.Are law enforcement gains from expanding forensic DNA testing worth the cost in civil liberties? I say yes. Because to me they seem the exception and not the rule. Overall I think forensic DNA has been a monumental success of the Genetic Revolution. Our margin of error daily becomes more minuscule as technology advances. And I think our government will enact laws to protect our civil liberties as the need becomes more apparent. There are already laws protecting Americans from the misuse of medical DNA information (Genetic Nondiscrimination Act) and similar ones will fall in place to keep the use of Forensic DNA in check. But you're welcome to challenge me on that. ;)
Here's a great list of pros and cons of banking DNA that I shamelessly plagiarized from the Human Genome Project's page.
0 comments:
Post a Comment