I've excerpted his arguments in red font, and responded in white.
"The problem is, and dare I say this, it doesn't look like Michelle Obama follows her own nutritionary, dietary advice."At 5'11" 175 lbs, Michelle's BMI is 24.4 and falls within the healthy range of 18.5 to 25. She prioritizes regular physical activity, even if it means waking up at 4:30 am to work out.
If Rush says a physically active woman with a normal BMI "doesn't look like" she eats healthy food, then perhaps it's his perception of what's healthy that's skewed. Case in point, "I'm trying to say that our First Lady does not project the image of women that you might see on the cover of the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue." That image is biologically unhealthy. Just because the word "Sport" is in the title, doesn't mean the magazine promotes an attainable standard. Carolyn Murphy, a Sports Illustrated Cover Girl, weighs in at 120 lbs, 5'9". Her BMI of 17.7 is below the recommended minimum.
"Our First Lady does not project the image....of a woman Alex Rodriguez might date every six months or what have you." Personally, I'd rather project the image of a woman the most powerful man in America (our President) might date for the rest of his life.
"And then we hear that she's out eating ribs at 1,500 calories a serving with 141 grams of fat per serving..." Rush, you inflate not only our First Lady's BMI, but also her caloric intake. Setting the record straight is The Vail Daily, who caught up with the owner of the restaurant at which Michelle ate to get the facts.
- Michelle's meal choice was sensibly sized: "A proper 5-ounce portion of protein is what nutritionists say we should have.”
- Michelle's meal choice was calorically conscientious: "A braised short rib is a relatively lean cut of beef...with most of the fat cooked off. The 5-ounce serving runs about 600 calories... a far cry from the 1,500 calories and 141 grams of fat" Rush accuses it of.
- Michelle's meal choice supported organic farming: "Let’s not forget that the 5-ounce rib is served with local kale, grown by students at Eagle’s Brush Creek Elementary School."
- Michelle's meal choice was nutrient packed: “Kale is one of nature’s super foods. There are more nutrients in the 3 ounces of kale we serve than you’ll get in a massive green salad.”
- Michelle's meal choice was burned off by skiing: "A skier will burn off about 6,000 calories during the course of a day."
"Haven't seen any evidence here that the uh, if (her advice) is being followed, that it works. That's all." I'm guessing that PubMed is not among your list of recently frequented Pubs. She's not making up eating advice on a whim, she's passing along USDA's recommendations that are based on scientific research. Her initiative endorses a well-balanced diet as specified by the Dietary Guidelines for Americans.
In conclusion, my dear Rush, here's an apt quote from motivational speaker, Geneen Roth: “Other ppl’s judgments are most often a reflection of their inability to accept themselves, not an indication of your shortcomings. People judge others about that which they judge in themselves; if they are uncomfortable with their weight, they are going to be very aware of your weight. If they are are afraid to eat chocolate cake, they will be disturbed when they see you eating it b/c it will bring their own fear and their own desire to do what you are doing. They will try to push away the external cause of their disturbance—you.”
Why are you so bothered by Michelle Obama? Why did you blow her meal choice way out of proportion? Is it because you project onto her what you dislike in yourself? In that case, the only fat hypocrit here, is you.
0 comments:
Post a Comment